24 October 2009
It was one of those meetings held behind closed doors that the kids always know about but don't dare speak of. At year end, we teachers have to sift through the fair and the failed to sort through who gets promoted, retained or laterally promoted (downgraded or upgraded; yes it is EXACTLY how it sounds). There are a lot of unhappy faces around that big wooden table in the conference room. There are also many sighs of relief. The tension is so thick you couldn't cut a fart in there without someone bleeding.
I'm not allowed to speak about what goes on in there. And for good reason too.
Teachers, at least this one time a year, are forced to play godlings and decide the fate of our children. It is NOT a position we want to be in. We all wish we didn't have to be here; or rather, that the kids who didn't study hard when it mattered, made it necessary for us to be here.
I can't tell you what words are spoken in there. Decisions had to be made for the good of the students. Yes, although many of the students will miss the forest for the trees and think that this occasion was prime for us to take our due 'vengeance' on them, nothing could be further from the truth.
We are all mothers, fathers, sisters and brothers. We cannot but imagine how painful it must be, even for the most dubiously deserving child, to be told that he will not be joining his friends next year in the express stream. Or worse, that she will have to repeat the next year. We can't help it. We hurt too.
We wonder if we were somehow responsible; not good enough or if we could have tried harder to help during the year. We do. Trust me.
What I can tell you, is that the outcome of our almost 3-hour meeting was fair. Every one of those students, good and bad, deserved what they received. It hardly comforts us when we think about it in bed tonight. But it's true.
As a wise old Spanish man once told me on a boat in Alaska: “You get as much as you put in.”




